What can you do to protect yourself as artist or Collector when gallery has gone Bankrupt

What can you do to protect yourself as artist or Collector when gallery has gone Bankrupt

Inside the Studio of Goran Go Edition Nr.17

A Bankruptcy of the art gallery and what can you do to protect yourself as Artist and Collector 

While enjoying my morning coffee and working on my latest creation, I came across a post from my dear fellow artist. The situation had escalated unexpectedly.

Her gallery, a familiar home for her artworks, had suddenly plunged into bankruptcy. Reading through the comments felt like watching a dramatic soap opera unfold, with artists divided between lamenting the loss and gearing up for a showdown.

artist sitting on stairs in front of a closed art gallery due to bancruptcy
The sudden closure of HangArt Gallery, entrapping the works of over 120 artists, casts a spotlight on the art world's unstable nature. It serves as a crucial alert for artists on the importance of due diligence and safeguarding themselves in gallery dealings.

As artists, we are driven by creativity and passion, yet this incident underscores the need to blend these with practical business sense. It's vital to be well-informed, proactive, and to continue creating with assurance and security. Steer clear of galleries that are as clogged as a 78-year-old smoker's arteries.

Also, critically evaluate whether your art is prepared for prestigious galleries, especially those representing artists less then 5 years. When ready, approach them with your professionally presented work, having thoroughly researched galleries that complement your style and standard.

I remember once a gallery that represented me. I made a unannounced visit, took them by surprise. This visit revealed a self-proclaimed fucked art expert, who knew as little about my and art in general as my late grandmother knew about the latest HALO game.

The questions I asked about my art were met with laughably uninformed answers. I removed my art from that gallery within two weeks. This highlighted the importance of knowing who represents your art; lack of knowledge on their part can damage your reputation, internationally and locally.


Here are few key strategies to consider for future gallery partnerships:

Insist on Formal Contracts:

Secure a detailed contract covering sales, commissions, consignment duration, and artwork return policies before entrusting your work to a gallery.

Research the Gallery Thoroughly:

Look into the gallery's financial health, reputation, and history. Seek feedback from artists who have previously exhibited there.

Diversify Exhibition Venues:

Explore beyond traditional galleries. Consider community art centers, online platforms, and pop-up events to lessen reliance on one venue.

Build Direct Relationships:

Engage with collectors and art enthusiasts directly for more control over sales and reduced dependency on galleries.

Keep Detailed Records:

Maintain meticulous documentation of your artworks and all related consignment correspondence.

Ensure Adequate Insurance:

Verify if the gallery provides insurance or if you need to arrange it independently.

Strengthen Your Online Presence:

Utilize personal websites and social media for art promotion and sales.

Be Financially Cautious:

Diversify your income sources and plan for financial sustainability beyond gallery sales.

Know Your Legal Rights:

In disputes, being knowledgeable about your legal options is crucial.

Host Personal Exhibitions:

While resource-intensive, this provides full control over your artwork's presentation.

Join Artist Collectives:

These organizations offer support, shared resources, and collective bargaining power.
    For dear collectors In case of a gallery's bankruptcy, it's vital to act quickly. Contact your lawyer and insurance provider immediately to understand your options and take necessary actions. Remember that each situation may have its unique complexities, so tailored legal and financial advice is crucial.


    In the United States laws are different than in Canada so here is few things you can do and ask if you live in US.     Legal Agreements and Documentation:

    Ensure all transactions with the gallery are accompanied by clear, legally binding contracts. These should detail the specifics of ownership, consignment, and sales. Keep all receipts, appraisals, and provenance documents in a secure and organized manner.

    Insurance:

    Obtain comprehensive insurance for your art collection. This should cover a range of scenarios, including the bankruptcy of a gallery holding your pieces. Regularly review and update the policy to reflect current values and conditions.

    Diversify Gallery Representation:

    Avoid placing all your artworks in a single gallery. Diversifying where your art is displayed and sold can mitigate risk.

     

    Regular Communication and Monitoring:

    Maintain regular contact with the gallery and stay informed about their financial health and business practices. This can provide early warning signs of potential trouble.

    Legal Counsel:

    Have a lawyer who specializes in art law. They can provide advice on protecting your interests and can act swiftly if issues arise.


    Art Market Research    :

    Keep abreast of market trends and the financial health of the art market in general. This can help in making informed decisions about where and how to sell or display your art.

    UCC-1 Filing:

    In the United States, consider a UCC-1 filing if you are consigning your artwork. This can establish your legal claim to the artwork in the event of the gallery's bankruptcy.

    Alternative Sales Channels:

    Explore other avenues for selling or showcasing your art, such as online platforms, auctions, or different galleries, as a contingency plan.

    Professional Network:

    Cultivate a network of trusted advisors, fellow collectors, and art professionals. They can offer valuable insights and support in challenging situations.

    Regular Appraisals:

    Have your collection regularly appraised to understand its current market value, which is crucial for insurance and resale purposes.

      In Canada, the equivalent to the UCC-1 filing in the United States is not exactly the same due to differences in legal systems. Canada does not have a unified commercial code like the U.S. Instead, each province and territory has its own laws and regulations regarding secured transactions, including those that would cover art consignment. The Canadian equivalent to a UCC-1 filing would generally involve registering a security interest under the Personal Property Security Act (PPSA) in the province where the debtor (in this case, the gallery) is located. The PPSA is a statute in each Canadian province and territory that governs the registration of security interests in personal property, which includes artwork. Key points regarding protecting your artwork in Canada through legal means are: Registration of Security Interest: To protect your interest in consigned artwork, you would register a security interest in the piece under the PPSA in the province where the gallery is located.

        Perfection of Security Interest:

        This process, known as "perfection," makes the security interest enforceable against third parties, including creditors in the event of bankruptcy.

        Specific Details:

        The registration should include specific details about the artwork to clearly identify it as the collateral.

        Timeliness:

        As with UCC-1 filings, timeliness is crucial. The sooner the security interest is registered after consigning the artwork, the better.

        Regular Updates and Renewals:

        Depending on the province, the registration may need to be renewed periodically. It's important to keep track of any renewal deadlines to maintain the protection of your security interest.

        Provincial Differences:

        Be aware that the application of the PPSA can vary from province to province. Each province may have different forms, fees, and procedures for registration.

        Monitoring the Gallery's Status:

        Stay informed about the financial status and creditworthiness of the gallery. Regularly reviewing the gallery's status can help you anticipate and prepare for potential issues.

        Additional Agreements:

        Besides PPSA registration, ensure that your consignment agreements with the gallery are robust and clear, outlining the terms of the consignment, insurance responsibilities, and what happens in the event of the gallery's insolvency.

          Insurance Considerations:

          As mentioned earlier, maintaining comprehensive insurance for your artwork is crucial. Ensure that your policy covers situations like the bankruptcy of a gallery holding your art.

          By taking these steps, you can establish a legal claim to your artwork in the event of the gallery's bankruptcy or insolvency in Canada, similar to how UCC-1 filings work in the United States. It's a proactive approach to protect your valuable assets in the art world. The incident involving my friend and 120 other artists (a gallery representing so many artists already raises questions) is regrettable but invaluable as a lesson.

          It highlights the necessity for us as artists and our collectors and buyers to carefully select our gallery partners and scrutinize who represents us. This consideration is key in our quest for reputable galleries.

          Remember, in the art world, the right partnerships can be as crucial as the art itself.

          Gorango
          Back to blog